Earnings Call Intelligence Subscribe
Management credibility scorecard

KeyCorp (KEY)

4 quarters tracked (Q4'25 to Q3'26) · latest call October 20, 2026
Get the next KEY call sheet
83%
Kept of 12 resolved
10
Kept or exceeded
2
Missed
15
Still pending
Share count, 3 yrs/yr · diluter

Score History

QuarterCall dateDisclosureFinancial qualityKeptMissed
Q3'26October 20, 20269/122 medium, 1 low flags10Call sheet →
Q2'26July 21, 20265/122 high, 3 medium, 2 low flags01Call sheet →
Q1'26April 16, 20269/123 medium, 3 low flags40Call sheet →
Q4'25January 20, 202610/122 medium, 5 low flags51Call sheet →
Disclosure: the 6-item rubric, each scored 0-2, out of 12. Financial quality: flagged indicators by severity. Kept and missed count the prior-quarter promises scored on that call.

Promise Ledger · All Quarters

MarkedStatusPromise
Q3'26PendingAssume a run rate of $300 million a quarter in buybacks for the back half of 2026
Q3 actual repurchase was $320M, consistent with the implied pace; full H2 period (including Q4) not yet complete.
Q3'26PendingContinue to expect to repurchase at least $1.3 billion of shares for the year
FY2026 not complete; ~$250M remains against the $1.3B target with Q4 to go.
Q3'26PendingAverage loans to increase 4% to 5%, average commercial loans 8% to 10% for 2026
FY2026 not complete. Current guide raised to ~5% average loans and ~10% commercial, a favorable revision.
Q3'26PendingFull year expense growth guide of 3% to 4%
FY2026 not complete. This quarter narrowed language to '~4%', effectively the top of the prior range.
Q3'26PendingFull year net charge-offs expected in the 40-45bps range
FY2026 not complete. Guide was tightened/lowered to 37-39bps this quarter, a favorable revision.
Q3'26PendingExpect to exit the year with NIM in the range of 3.0% to 3.05%
FY2026 not complete. Guide revised down to 'approximately 3%' this quarter, a downward revision of the prior range, not yet a miss since the period hasn't ended.
Q3'26PendingExpect $3 billion client deposit growth in second half of 2026
H2 2026 not yet complete at this call. Management says Q3 alone delivered $2.8B and they have 'nearly achieved' the full $3B target with Q4 still to come; tracking ahead of plan but not formally closed.
Q3'26ExceededExpect third quarter investment banking fees to be up 20%+ quarter-over-quarter
IB and debt placement fees came in at $214M, +27% sequential, beating the prior quarter's guide.
Q2'26PendingExpense growth of 3-4% for full year
Reiterated despite higher incentive comp pressures
Q2'26PendingAverage commercial loan growth of 6-8% for 2026
Raised to 8-10% but quality deteriorating with tighter spreads
Q2'26PendingRepurchase at least $1.3 billion shares in 2026
On track with $340M in Q2, raised from $1.2B prior guide
Q2'26PendingMid-single digit investment banking fee growth for full year
Still claiming achievable despite Q2 miss and weak Q3 guide
Q2'26PendingGenerate 15% ROTCE by end of 2027
Reiterated but with 'even greater confidence' qualifier suggesting concern
Q2'26MissedExit year with NIM of approximately 3.05%
Walked back to 3.0-3.05% range after only 2bp expansion in Q2
Q1'26PendingExpense growth of 3-4% in 2026
Reiterated guidance despite $1B technology investment
Q1'26ExceededNet interest income growth of 8-10% in 2026
Raised to 9-10% based on strong Q1 performance
Q1'26ExceededShare repurchases of at least $300M per quarter
Bought $400M in Q1, raised full-year target to $1.3B
Q1'26ExceededCommercial loan growth of about 5% in 2026
Now guiding 6-8% growth, raised from previous 5% target
Q1'26PendingInvestment banking fee growth of about 5% in 2026
Q1 was strong but guiding Q2 down, full-year target at risk
Q1'26ExceededNet interest margin above 2.75%-2.8% in Q4 2025
Hit 2.82% in Q4, now targeting 3%+ by year-end 2026
Q1'26PendingReturn on tangible common equity of 15%+ by year-end 2027
At 13%+ in Q1, making progress but still 200+ bps to go
Q4'25MissedIncrease frontline staff by approximately 10%
Achieved just over 9%, with investment banking at only 5% vs 10% target
Q4'25DeliveredFull-year expenses approximately 4%
Achieved 4.6% expense growth within targeted range
Q4'25ExceededFourth quarter share repurchases of approximately $100M
Executed $200M, double the commitment at $18 average price
Q4'25ExceededFee growth between 5-6%, toward higher end assuming M&A pickup
Delivered 7.5% fee growth despite limited M&A activity
Q4'25DeliveredFull-year net interest income growth of about 22%
Achieved 23% growth, at high end of 20-22% guidance range
Q4'25ExceededFourth quarter investment banking fees similar to record Q4 2024 level (~$220M)
Delivered $243M, 10% above target, driven by debt capital markets
Each row is a promise from the prior call, scored against the quarter in "Marked". Kept-promise rate counts resolved promises only; pending is excluded.
Promise-kept rate counts resolved promises only (pending excluded).
Scores, kept-promise rates, and flags on this site reflect the author's opinion, applying a stated methodology to statements management made on public earnings calls. Informational and educational purposes only - not investment advice, a recommendation, or an offer to buy or sell any security. Sources believed reliable but not guaranteed; the author may hold positions in the securities discussed.

Follow what management promises next

Get free previews of our earnings-call research: the key changes, management scores, and questions worth investigating. Subscribe for full call sheets and deeper analysis.

Subscriptions are managed by Substack. If the form does not load, subscribe directly. Or follow the RSS feed.