Earnings Call Intelligence Subscribe
Home › Credibility Index › SMCI
Management credibility scorecard

Super Micro Computer (SMCI)

7 quarters tracked (Q2'25 to Q4'26) · latest call August 11, 2026
Get the next SMCI call sheet
55%
Kept of 33 resolved
18
Kept or exceeded
15
Missed
7
Still pending
Share count, 3 yrs/yr · heavy diluter

Score History

QuarterCall dateDisclosureFinancial qualityKeptMissed
Q4'26August 11, 20264/123 high, 2 medium flags00Call sheet →
Q3'26May 5, 202610/123 high, 2 medium, 1 low flags32Call sheet →
Q2'26February 3, 20268/123 high, 5 medium flags42Call sheet →
Q1'26November 4, 20253/123 high, 4 medium, 1 low flags23Call sheet →
Q4'25August 5, 20258/124 medium, 4 low flags52Call sheet →
Q3'252025-05-064/121 high, 5 medium, 2 low flags32Call sheet →
Q2'25February 11, 20255/122 high, 6 medium, 1 low flags14Call sheet →
Disclosure: the 6-item rubric, each scored 0-2, out of 12. Financial quality: flagged indicators by severity. Kept and missed count the prior-quarter promises scored on that call.

Promise Ledger · All Quarters

MarkedStatusPromise
Q3'26MissedSupply chain cost pressures to improve
Actually got worse. Memory and SSD prices 'double, triple, more than triple' with duration uncertainty.
Q3'26ExceededDouble-digit DCBBS profit contribution by end of calendar 2026
Upgraded to '20% of net income' target over next 2 years, ahead of original timeline.
Q3'26PendingAt least $40 billion full year revenue
Maintained guidance with new range $38.9-40.4B. Q4 guide suggests confidence in achieving target.
Q3'26DeliveredDCBBS to meaningfully contribute in second half fiscal '26
Software revenue hit $46M, up from $34M. Charles now targeting 20% of profits 'in next 2 years.'
Q3'26ExceededGross margins up 30 basis points relative to Q2 levels
Delivered 370bps improvement to 10.1% vs Q2's 6.4%. Major beat driven by mix and cost controls.
Q3'26MissedQ3 revenue of 'at least $12.3 billion'
Delivered $10.2B, 17% below minimum guidance due to customer site readiness delays.
Q2'26MissedCustomer diversification as important direction
Went opposite direction to 63% concentration with single customer
Q2'26PendingMargin improvement as we go through transition
Still promising improvement but timeline keeps extending
Q2'26DeliveredMalaysia facility to contribute greatly
Confirmed Malaysia now contributing to production
Q2'26DeliveredDCBBS to become meaningful contributor
Now 4% of profits with specific double-digit target by calendar year-end
Q2'26DeliveredSequential growth through fiscal 2026
Q2 revenue up 153% sequentially, guiding Q3 up another 17%
Q2'26ExceededAt least $36 billion full year revenue
Raised to $40 billion, $4B increase
Q2'26MissedDecember quarter to be low watermark for gross margins
Q2 margins fell further to 6.4% vs 9.5% in Q1, making Q1 the actual low point so far
Q1'26MissedBack to 15% gross margins as long-term target
Target completely disappeared from prepared remarks. David said they'll 'give guidance when we can see it clearly.'
Q1'26MissedAdding 'a few more' 10%+ customers in fiscal '26
Actually lost half their large customers (from 4 to 2). Promise quietly dropped.
Q1'26PendingDCBBS will 'ramp up very soon' with 'much higher' margins
Still in early shipping phase. Charles now says 'I hope very soon' - confidence regression.
Q1'26DeliveredGross margins similar to Q4 fiscal '25 levels (~9.6%)
Came in at 9.5%, but guided next quarter down 300 bps.
Q1'26MissedQ1 revenue between $6 billion and $7 billion
Delivered $5B, citing customer specification changes and logistics delays.
Q1'26ExceededAt least $33 billion total revenue for fiscal 2026
Raised to at least $36B. However, this came with explicit cash flow constraints.
Q4'25ExceededStrong Q4 performance after Q3 platform transition delays
26% sequential revenue growth showed recovery from Q3 weakness
Q4'25DeliveredMalaysia campus shipping by end of fiscal year
'Malaysia campus began shipping products to partners' during Q4
Q4'25PendingB300/GB300 platforms 'this summer' (Q3 call)
Now says 'pretty much ready to go' but 'waiting for NVIDIA' - dependency risk
Q4'25DeliveredLaunch DCBBS 'in the coming days' (Q3 call)
'Officially introduced' DCBBS last quarter and started shipping components
Q4'25MissedGross margins approximately 10% (Q3 guidance)
Delivered 9.6% - missed by 40bps despite volume recovery
Q4'25DeliveredNon-GAAP diluted EPS $0.40 to $0.50 (Q3 guidance)
Delivered $0.41 - at low end but within range
Q4'25DeliveredGAAP diluted EPS $0.30 to $0.40 (Q3 guidance)
Delivered $0.31 - at low end but within range
Q4'25MissedQ4 revenues of at least $6 billion (Q3 guidance)
Delivered $5.8B - fell short of minimum guidance by $200M
Q3'25PendingExpanding DCBBS quarter-after-quarter
Still promising launch 'in coming days' - pattern of overpromising timelines
Q3'25DeliveredMalaysia campus shipping products to partners
Confirmed shipping began, full enablement by July
Q3'25DeliveredVolume shipments of B200 HGX and GB200 NVL72
Did begin shipping but volumes constrained by NVIDIA allocation
Q3'25Missed$40 billion potential for fiscal 2026
Explicitly refused to provide 2026 guidance, complete reversal from prior confidence
Q3'25Missed$23.5-25B revenue for fiscal 2025
Quietly walked back to 'at least $6B Q4' without confirming full-year range
Q3'25PendingCalendar year 2025 growth could repeat 2023 if not better
Still claiming this despite Q3 miss and reduced visibility
Q3'25DeliveredFiscal year 2024 10-K and Q1/Q2 10-Qs filed by February 25th, 2025
Actually achieved compliance and regained financial credibility
Q2'25MissedCash generation improvement from working capital normalization
Burned $240M in operations vs generating $407M prior quarter
Q2'25MissedGross margin improvement as quarters progress
Margins compressed 140bps, Q3 guided only to 12%
Q2'25PendingStrong relationship with NVIDIA, no allocation changes
Now admits allocation constraints, 'volume demand way much bigger'
Q2'25DeliveredWorking diligently to select new auditor quickly
BDO selected and working on audit completion
Q2'25MissedSequential revenue increases in medium-term
Q3 guided flat to down sequentially
Q2'25MissedMalaysia manufacturing to begin later in Q1 quarter
Malaysia utilization still only 1% - facility barely operational
Each row is a promise from the prior call, scored against the quarter in "Marked". Kept-promise rate counts resolved promises only; pending is excluded.
Promise-kept rate counts resolved promises only (pending excluded).
Scores, kept-promise rates, and flags on this site reflect the author's opinion, applying a stated methodology to statements management made on public earnings calls. Informational and educational purposes only - not investment advice, a recommendation, or an offer to buy or sell any security. Sources believed reliable but not guaranteed; the author may hold positions in the securities discussed.

Follow what management promises next

Get free previews of our earnings-call research: the key changes, management scores, and questions worth investigating. Subscribe for full call sheets and deeper analysis.

Subscriptions are managed by Substack. If the form does not load, subscribe directly. Or follow the RSS feed.