Earnings Call Intelligence Subscribe
Management credibility scorecard

Morgan Stanley (MS)

4 quarters tracked (Q4'25 to Q3'26) · latest call October 14, 2026
Get the next MS call sheet
76%
Kept of 17 resolved
13
Kept or exceeded
4
Missed
4
Still pending
Share count, 3 yrs/yr · flat

Score History

QuarterCall dateDisclosureFinancial qualityKeptMissed
Q3'26October 14, 20267/122 medium, 2 low flags01Call sheet →
Q2'26July 15, 20265/123 high, 4 medium flags32Call sheet →
Q1'26April 15, 20269/121 medium, 6 low flags41Call sheet →
Q4'25January 15, 202610/122 medium, 4 low flags60Call sheet →
Disclosure: the 6-item rubric, each scored 0-2, out of 12. Financial quality: flagged indicators by severity. Kept and missed count the prior-quarter promises scored on that call.

Promise Ledger · All Quarters

MarkedStatusPromise
Q3'26PendingIf over time it's clear that the margin hurdle is not enough and we want to take it up, we'll do that... that's something we're going to want to give a real consideration to... That's something that would be addressed at the end of the year.
Year-end review remains pending. Q3 margin of 30.4% versus 30.5% and the scale commentary do not establish that the review was cancelled.
Q3'26PendingWe continue to expect our annual tax rate to be between 22% and 23%.
Annual period remains incomplete. Quarterly rates may vary. Q3 was 23.3%, and Q4 was expected slightly above that, with annual guidance unchanged. Evaluate the full-year weighted calculation before alleging a miss.
Q3'26MissedFor the third quarter, we expect a modest sequential increase in NII.
NII actually declined sequentially to $2.2 billion from $2.3 billion, explicitly described as 'down modestly'. This is a clean guidance miss on a metric with a defined quarter-end deadline.
Q2'26DeliveredQ1: 'We'll continue to invest strategically across the firm'
Tech spend increasing per commentary, though no numbers
Q2'26DeliveredQ1: 'Investment banking pipelines remain steady'
IB revenue up 14% QoQ to $2.4B
Q2'26MissedQ1: 'Fee-based flows generating $54B record'
Dropped to $39B in Q2, -28% sequential
Q2'26DeliveredQ1: 'Global activity is building'
Asia equities revenue surge validates this call
Q2'26PendingQ1: 'Sponsor monetization is gaining momentum'
Added 'selectively' qualifier, suggesting narrower opportunity than promised
Q2'26MissedQ1: 'We expect NII to build over the course of the year'
Now just 'modest' Q3 increase, clearly backing off full-year build
Q1'26ExceededEfficiency ratio target of 70% or better
Delivered 65% efficiency ratio in Q1, well below 70% target.
Q1'26ExceededContinue to opportunistically buy back stock
Bought back $1.75B in Q1 vs $1.5B in Q4, increased pace.
Q1'26DeliveredPrudent dividend growth comes first
Raised quarterly dividend 7.5 cents for fourth year in a row to $1.00 per share.
Q1'26DeliveredContinue to invest strategically across the firm
Closed EquityZen acquisition, launched digital asset pilot, moved forward with bank reorg.
Q1'26MissedNII to remain roughly flat quarter over quarter in Q1
NII increased to $2.2B in Q1 vs $2.1B in Q4, so it actually grew rather than stayed flat.
Q1'26PendingExpect our 2026 tax rate to be between 22% and 23%
Q1 came in at 19.6% due to timing, but they reaffirmed full-year 22-23% guidance.
Q4'25DeliveredOperating leverage demonstration if markets remained constructive
Efficiency ratio improved to 68.4%, wealth margins hit 31.4%
Q4'25ExceededWorkplace asset migration continuing above historical $60B average
Hit $99B full year, 65% above historical average
Q4'25DeliveredContinued fee-based flow strength above $40B quarterly
Third consecutive quarter above $40B, described as 'industry first'
Q4'25Exceeded'Strong pipelines' in investment banking would translate to activity
IB revenues up 47% YoY to $2.4B, advisory crossed $1B milestone
Q4'25DeliveredQ4 tax rate expected to be 'approximately 24%'
Q4 tax rate was 23.2%, close to 24% guidance
Q4'25DeliveredQ4 NII expected to see 'modest sequential gain' from Q3 levels
NII grew from $2.0B to $2.1B, meeting guidance for modest increase
Each row is a promise from the prior call, scored against the quarter in "Marked". Kept-promise rate counts resolved promises only; pending is excluded.
Promise-kept rate counts resolved promises only (pending excluded).
Scores, kept-promise rates, and flags on this site reflect the author's opinion, applying a stated methodology to statements management made on public earnings calls. Informational and educational purposes only - not investment advice, a recommendation, or an offer to buy or sell any security. Sources believed reliable but not guaranteed; the author may hold positions in the securities discussed.

Follow what management promises next

Get free previews of our earnings-call research: the key changes, management scores, and questions worth investigating. Subscribe for full call sheets and deeper analysis.

Subscriptions are managed by Substack. If the form does not load, subscribe directly. Or follow the RSS feed.