Macerich (MAC)

Management Credibility Scorecard · 5 quarters tracked (Q1'25 - Q1'26)
Last updated May 7, 2026 · latest call analyzed
100%
Kept of 18 resolved
18
Kept / Exceeded
0
Missed
14
Still Pending

Grade History

QuarterDisclosure QualityFinancial Quality
Q1'25 →B+B
Q2'25 →A-B+
Q3'25 →B+B
Q4'25 →B+B-
Q1'26 →A-B+

Promise Ledger · All Quarters

MarkedPromiseStatus
Q1'26⏳$2B total disposition target
$1.3B completed, additional $300-400M expected by year-end
pending
Q1'26⏳Substantially complete new leasing objectives by year-end 2026
On track with 250 of 1,000 leases remaining, 125 in LOI stage
pending
Q1'26⏳Go-forward NOI growth acceleration in 2026 vs 2025's 1.8%
Tracking to at least 3% for full year 2026, Q1 at 1.2% with weather impact
pending
Q1'26✅All 30 anchor stores committed under Path Forward plan
All 30 committed as promised, 3 additional signings in Q1
delivered
Q1'26✅$100M SNO pipeline by 2025 year-end
Delivered $107M vs $100M target, now $116M in Q1
exceeded
Q1'26✅Leasing speedometer at 70% by 2025 year-end
Delivered 76% vs 70% target, now at 83% currently
exceeded
Q4'25⏳Return to providing earnings guidance beginning in 2027
Reaffirmed this timeline
pending
Q4'25⏳Path-Forward plan 3.0 update at REIT Week in June
Reaffirmed this commitment for mid-2026
pending
Q4'25⏳Substantially complete $2B disposition program by end of 2026
At $1.3B completed, on track but management dropped specific end-2026 timeline reference
pending
Q4'25✅$100-150M in outparcel/land sales for 2025
$130M sold or under contract vs $100-150M target
delivered
Q4'25✅South Plains loan expected to be in technical default
Actually secured 4-year extension at favorable 4.2% rate
exceeded
Q4'25✅All 30 anchor replacements committed in Path-Forward plan
All 30 now committed as promised
delivered
Q4'25✅Leasing speedometer 70% by year-end 2025
Achieved 76% vs 70% target
exceeded
Q4'25✅SNO pipeline target of $100M by year-end 2025
Delivered $107M vs $100M target
exceeded
Q3'25✅Target leverage to be leverage neutral from Crabtree acquisition
Used $50M ATM to achieve leverage neutrality as stated
delivered
Q3'25⏳$2B disposition program substantially complete by end 2026
At $1.2B completed, with identified path to $1.4-1.5B range
pending
Q3'25⏳Low-to-mid 6x leverage by 2028
Currently 7.76x, down from 8.7x at start but need continued progress
pending
Q3'25✅4 million square feet average leasing in 2025-2026
Already at 5.4M sq ft YTD, well ahead of annual target
exceeded
Q3'25⏳$100M SNO pipeline by year-end
At $99M today, on track to exceed target
pending
Q3'25✅70% completion on leasing speedometer by year-end 2025
Hit 70% in Q3, well ahead of year-end target
exceeded
Q2'25⏳Low to mid-6x leverage range over next couple years
Flat at 7.9x despite Crabtree acquisition
pending
Q2'25⏳Substantial completion of Path Forward plan by mid-2026
Ahead on leasing, on track for timeline
pending
Q2'25✅$100-150M outparcel sales for 2025
$100M sold or under contract already
delivered
Q2'25✅70% new deal completion by year-end 2025
At 65% in Q2, on pace to exceed 70% target
exceeded
Q2'25✅$100M SNO pipeline by year-end 2025
At $87M in Q2, on track to exceed $100M target
exceeded
Q2'25✅4 million square feet average leasing target for 2025-2026
Hit 4.3M sq ft through Q2 alone - way ahead of pace
exceeded
Q1'25✅Same-store NOI 'roughly flat for the next couple of years'
Updated guidance to 3-4% growth in 2026 for go-forward portfolio - significant upgrade
delivered
Q1'25⏳Substantially complete on disposition program by end of 2026
On track with $1.1B completed toward $2B target
pending
Q1'25✅SNO pipeline $66M with $27M to be realized in 2025
Pipeline grew to $80M, $25M targeted for 2025 with $6M already realized
exceeded
Q1'25⏳$100M to $150M outparcel sales in 2025
$77M completed or under contract, 77% of target achieved
pending
Q1'25✅70% new deal completion by year-end 2025
Already at 60% vs 39% last quarter, ahead of schedule
exceeded
Q1'25⏳Targeting 4 million square feet of leasing in 2025 and 2026
Q1 delivered 2.6M sq ft, on track if pace continues
pending
Get the next MAC call sheet the day it drops.
Subscribe to Call Sheet Daily →
Every missed promise →  ·  Metrics that vanished →  ·  All credibility pages →
About Research ↗ · Credibility Index · Missed Promises · Screens · 13F Holdings · Subscribe
Promise-kept rate counts resolved promises only (pending excluded).
Grades, kept-promise rates, and flags on this site reflect the author's opinion, applying a stated methodology to statements management made on public earnings calls. Informational and educational purposes only - not investment advice, a recommendation, or an offer to buy or sell any security. Sources believed reliable but not guaranteed; the author may hold positions in the securities discussed.