Earnings Call Intelligence Subscribe
Home › Credibility Index › FIVE
Management credibility scorecard

Five Below (FIVE)

4 quarters tracked (Q3'25 to Q2'26) · latest call September 2, 2026
Get the next FIVE call sheet
95%
Kept of 22 resolved
21
Kept or exceeded
1
Missed
1
Still pending
Share count, 3 yrs/yr · flat

Score History

QuarterCall dateDisclosureFinancial qualityKeptMissed
Q2'26September 2, 20268/122 medium, 4 low flags50Call sheet →
Q1'26June 3, 20267/122 medium, 4 low flags50Call sheet →
Q4'25March 18, 20269/123 medium, 3 low flags51Call sheet →
Q3'25December 3, 20258/121 high, 4 medium, 3 low flags60Call sheet →
Disclosure: the 6-item rubric, each scored 0-2, out of 12. Financial quality: flagged indicators by severity. Kept and missed count the prior-quarter promises scored on that call.

Promise Ledger · All Quarters

MarkedStatusPromise
Q2'26DeliveredSquishy Dumpling event characterized as not designed to be a meaningful catalyst to the Q2 comp profile
Management confirmed this quarter that squishy dumplings were a 'low single-digit contributor to our comp growth,' consistent with the prior caution.
Q2'26ExceededQ2 FY26 approximately 50 net new store openings
Actual net new store openings were 52, modestly above plan.
Q2'26ExceededQ2 FY26 adjusted net income guide of $68M at the midpoint, adjusted EPS of $1.23
Actual adjusted net income was $93M with EPS of $1.68, well above guidance.
Q2'26ExceededQ2 FY26 adjusted operating margin guide of 7%
Actual adjusted operating margin was 9%, 200bps above the guided midpoint.
Q2'26ExceededQ2 FY26 sales guide of $1.18-1.2B, comp growth of 7-9%
Actual Q2 sales came in at $1.3B with 14% comp growth, well above the top end of guidance.
Q1'26DeliveredDiversify vendor base due to tariff impacts
Management cited vendor diversification success and improved negotiating position
Q1'26DeliveredContinued investment in store labor during peak periods
Maintained labor investment strategy, cited as driver of in-stock positions
Q1'26DeliveredFocus on quality locations over quantity for new stores
New store productivity described as 'outsized,' opened 8 record-breaking stores in Pacific Northwest
Q1'26ExceededComp growth of 3-5% for fiscal 2026
Q1 came in at 23%, raising full year to 6-8%
Q1'26ExceededOperating margin expansion of 100 bps to 10.9%
Already at 12% in Q1, ahead of full-year target
Q1'26Pending150 net new stores for fiscal 2026
On track with 49 stores in Q1, guidance maintained
Q4'25DeliveredShrink mitigation efforts showing results
50bps improvement from inventory counts, first quantified benefit they've disclosed
Q4'25DeliveredMarketing effectiveness driving traffic growth
Traffic growth continued, contributed to 15.4% comps alongside ticket growth
Q4'25ExceededNew store productivity in line with expectations
Mid-80s productivity vs historical mid-70s, Pacific Northwest records validate site selection
Q4'25ExceededStrong holiday performance expected
Called it 'strongest holiday performance since becoming public company' - clear beat
Q4'25DeliveredTariff impacts largely mitigated at unit level
They maintained pricing but took 160bps gross margin hit, so 'largely' was accurate framing
Q4'25MissedInventory growth per store would moderate by end of fiscal year
Still up 9% per store in Q4 vs their expectation of moderation - they're less confident in demand predictability
Q3'25DeliveredContinue pricing simplification strategy
Majority of items now at whole price points as planned
Q3'25DeliveredBetter inventory flow and improved in-stock positions
Management confirmed better inventory flow supported sales beat
Q3'25ExceededAugust physical inventory counts to show shrink initiative benefits
Delivered 70bps shrink benefit vs no specific promise
Q3'25DeliveredApproximately 50 net new stores in Q3
Opened 49 net new stores, essentially in line
Q3'25Exceeded160 basis points unmitigated tariff impact in Q3
Impact was better than expected due to improved price elasticity
Q3'25ExceededQ3 comp guidance of 5-7%
Delivered 14.3% comp, beating by 730bps at midpoint
Each row is a promise from the prior call, scored against the quarter in "Marked". Kept-promise rate counts resolved promises only; pending is excluded.
Promise-kept rate counts resolved promises only (pending excluded).
Scores, kept-promise rates, and flags on this site reflect the author's opinion, applying a stated methodology to statements management made on public earnings calls. Informational and educational purposes only - not investment advice, a recommendation, or an offer to buy or sell any security. Sources believed reliable but not guaranteed; the author may hold positions in the securities discussed.

Follow what management promises next

Get free previews of our earnings-call research: the key changes, management scores, and questions worth investigating. Subscribe for full call sheets and deeper analysis.

Subscriptions are managed by Substack. If the form does not load, subscribe directly. Or follow the RSS feed.