A-
Overall grade
B+
Financial quality
The sleeper story is that Oscar is becoming the ACA market - at 30% share with younger, healthier members, they're approaching the scale where risk adjustment becomes predictable rather than volatile. Everyone's obsessing over market contraction fears while missing the $750M earnings swing they're guiding to as competitors retreat. The binding constraint isn't demand or even enhanced subsidies - it's execution on the operational leverage they've built through AI and broker distribution. 'The impact of AI on our efficiency is unparalleled in my 40 years in this industry' - Bertolini isn't known for hyperbole. My view changes if the 3M paid membership target by Q2 doesn't hold or if risk adjustment surprises continue despite their improved data and market position.
The 30-second version
- The sleeper story: Risk adjustment is becoming a feature, not a bug, as OSCR captures younger, healthier members
- Massive profitability inflection masked by everyone obsessing over ACA market contraction fears
- The 400K membership rolloff is front-loaded and predictable, not a quarterly surprise
What changed this quarter
| Metric | Prior | This quarter |
|---|---|---|
| Total Revenue | $3.0B (+23% YoY) | $11.7B (+28% YoY) |
| Medical Loss Ratio | 88.5% (+380 bps YoY) | 87.4% (+570 bps YoY) |
| SG&A Expense Ratio | 17.5% (-150 bps YoY) | 17.5% (-160 bps YoY) |
| Operating Loss | $129M loss | $396M loss |
| Membership | 2.1M (+28% YoY) | 3.4M enrolled, 3M paid expected Q2 2026 |
| Market Share | 17% across footprint | 30% across footprint |
| Risk Adjustment % of Premiums | High mid-teens | 18.5% (2025), 20% guided (2026) |
| Average Member Age | 39 years | 38 years |
Accountability tracked
7 new promises made4 narrative shifts flagged7 prior promises graded
Inside the full report
The complete write-up covers the full promise ledger with kept/missed calls, disclosure-quality scoring, the metrics-vanished check, verification items, and the questions to ask next quarter.
Subscribe to Call Sheet Daily →