AerCap Holdings (AER)

Management Credibility Scorecard · 5 quarters tracked (Q1'25 - Q1'26)
Last updated April 29, 2026 · latest call analyzed
94%
Kept of 18 resolved
17
Kept / Exceeded
1
Missed
9
Still Pending

Grade History

QuarterDisclosure QualityFinancial Quality
Q1'25 →B+B
Q2'25 →B+B+
Q3'25 →A+A
Q4'25 →B+B
Q1'26 →AA

Promise Ledger · All Quarters

MarkedPromiseStatus
Q1'26⏳Investigating aeroderivatives for data centers
Discussions continuing but admit long sales cycle and unclear long-term demand
pending
Q1'26✅$1B share buyback program authorized in December
New $1B program announced, previous one presumably utilized
delivered
Q1'26⏳Maintenance contribution to normalize
Will remain elevated through first half, normal in second half
pending
Q1'26⏳Spirit aircraft returning to service 'latter part of this year'
Timeline remains on track but some will slip to 2027
pending
Q1'26✅Asset sales of $2-3B for 2026
Now expecting over $3B with strong Q1 performance
exceeded
Q1'26✅Adjusted EPS range of $12-13 for 2026
Raised to $14.50 after Q1 beat
exceeded
Q4'25✅Q3: Sales for full year to be over $3B
Hit $3.9B, exceeding the updated projection
delivered
Q4'25✅Q3: Spirit aircraft acquisition provides superior timing/pricing
Secured 52 firm plus 45 options, claiming better terms than direct OEM order
delivered
Q4'25✅Q3: Majority of Spirit engine costs in Q4
Took majority of engine shop costs in Q4 as indicated, though some timing uncertainty remains
delivered
Q4'25✅Q3: Expected first 777 freighter delivery in September
First converted 777-300ER freighter delivered as promised
delivered
Q4'25✅Q3: Increased 2025 EPS guidance to $13.70
Delivered $15.37 adjusted EPS, $1.67 above guidance
exceeded
Q4'25✅Q3: Raised full-year sales volume guidance to $2.5B
Delivered $3.9B in sales, 56% above updated guidance
exceeded
Q3'25✅Ukraine recoveries to continue
$475M in Q3 bringing total to ~$2.9B since 2023
delivered
Q3'25⏳Air France-KLM partnership to finalize later in 2025
Still expected per Q3 call, but no specific timeline given
pending
Q3'25⏳$3 billion additional equipment purchases through 2025
Still on track per Q3 commentary
pending
Q3'25⏳Stock-based compensation to return to ~$30M/quarter
Not specifically updated in Q3 call, need to verify in Q4
pending
Q3'25✅Sales to be around $2.5 billion for full year 2025
Now expecting over $3 billion with Q3's $1.5B alone, 20% above guidance
exceeded
Q2'25✅Continue to deploy excess capital effectively
Deployed $3B in new equipment and $1B+ in share repurchases year-to-date
delivered
Q2'25⏳Air France-KLM partnership to be finalized later in the year
Still in progress, no specific timeline given beyond 'later in the year'
pending
Q2'25⏳Stock-based compensation to normalize to around $30M quarterly
Q2 was higher than normal due to upfront recognition, normalization expected going forward
pending
Q2'25⏳Expected around $2.5 billion in sales for full year
Reiterated $2.5B target with $470M in held-for-sale inventory
pending
Q2'25✅We'd expect to be in the top half of the $9.30-$10.30 EPS range
Raised guidance to $11.60, well above the top half of prior range
exceeded
Q1'25❌Extension rates around 90% in recent quarters
84% in Q1, management noted 'little bit lower' due to selective non-renewals
missed
Q1'25✅Continue generating strong gains on sale
35% unlevered margin on $177M Q1 gains, though below Q4 record
delivered
Q1'25✅Net maintenance contribution $30-40M per quarter average
$82M in Q1 but management says timing-driven, maintaining guidance
exceeded
Q1'25✅$1B share repurchase program deployment
$1B+ already deployed through April, new $500M program added
delivered
Q1'25✅2025 EPS guidance of $8.50-9.50 excluding gains on sale
Raised to $9.30-10.30 after Q1 outperformance
exceeded
Get the next AER call sheet the day it drops.
Subscribe to Call Sheet Daily →
Every missed promise →  ·  Metrics that vanished →  ·  All credibility pages →
About Research ↗ · Credibility Index · Missed Promises · Screens · 13F Holdings · Subscribe
Promise-kept rate counts resolved promises only (pending excluded).
Grades, kept-promise rates, and flags on this site reflect the author's opinion, applying a stated methodology to statements management made on public earnings calls. Informational and educational purposes only - not investment advice, a recommendation, or an offer to buy or sell any security. Sources believed reliable but not guaranteed; the author may hold positions in the securities discussed.